Hey LizM! I'm actually not very familiar with much of Columbus so I'm not sure where Darby is. I'm about an hour away from Columbus, but I have heard of Hilliard. I go to Ontario High School, have you heard of it?
When I visited Butler, I really enjoyed how close it was to Indianapolis, it did kinda remind me of what I've seen of Columbus too. I've never been to the short north area near OSU campus, but I've heard of it and everyone always says how nice it is. What made you choose Butler? Because right now my choice is between Butler and Otterbein. I liked Butler a little more, but of course it will most likely come down to who offers me more scholarships (so my mother says) lol.